CMHC Insists Mortgage Stress Test Needed to Protect Economy – In response to the growing requests from industry groups to moderate the stress test Evan Siddall, chief executive of the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp (CMHC) has written a letter to the House of Commons finance committee outlining that, “the mortgage stress test is exactly the kind of policy we need to protect our economy.” The stress test must be maintained to prevent a potential financial crisis from a “debt-fuelled real estate boom.”
The consequences of such a boom are serious and collapses of asset bubbles have historically created panic. Ten years after the last so-called crash, Mr Siddall mentions that “we have fallen into the ‘this time is different’ trap of complacency.” He adds in the letter that “We [CMHC] have a responsibility to prevent these tragedies. And while I’m not predicting, it nonetheless could happen here: Of the 46 banking crises for which we have housing data, over two-thirds were preceded by real estate boom and bust cycles.”
Canada’s banking regulator, the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI), introduced a stress test on uninsured mortgages – those with a down payment of 20% or more – in January, 2018, to curb risky lending practices, bringing such mortgages more in line with those of buyers putting down less than 20%. The stress-test rule requires borrowers to prove they could still afford their mortgages even if interest rates were two percentage points higher than the rate they negotiated with their banks, providing an affordability cushion if rates were to rise.
Since the start of 2018, home sales have fallen sharply, dropping 11% nationally last year. Sales declined the most in Canada’s two most expensive cities – 32% in the Vancouver region and 16% in the Greater Toronto Area – in 2018.
When comparing the first four months of 2018 to 2019 Markham real estate sales have increased by 12.6% and in Stouffville, real estate sales have increased by 6.9%. In fact, York Region as a whole has witnessed an increase of 11.7% in sales activity when compared to the same period in 2018.
Real estate groups have voiced their opinion and complained that the stress test is having unintended consequences and is keeping would-be buyers out of the market. Mr Siddall countered this in his letter by stating that the consequences are not unintended and that the policy is working as anticipated.
Part of the opinions issued by the industry suggested that it is safer now for the government to adjust the stress test because interest rates have risen since it was first implemented, reducing the risk of a major rate shock. Mr Siddall added that the main goal of the stress test is not to protect against interest-rate increases but to ensure Canadians can afford their mortgages if they face personal financial stresses.
The largest warning issued by Mr Siddall was about the growing level of household debt in Canada and how it is going to affect future spending if borrowers must dedicate more money to repaying their loans.
While the federal government announced a new first-time home buyers program in its March budget this year, which will provide $1.25-billion in interest-free loans over three years, Mr Siddall said its modest scale will have “a near insignificant impact on prices.”
The market continues to react differently to the stress test across the country. The OSFI has repeatedly said it is monitoring the impact of the B-20 stress-test rule on the Canadian housing market but has not offered any signal it could relax the measure.
CMHC Insists Mortgage Stress Test Needed to Protect Economy written by Benczik Team Realty
Rachel Kavanagh from Re/MAX All-Stars Benczik Kavanagh Real Estate Team provides an update based on the results from last months Toronto Real Estate Board transactions. Rachel covers Markham, Stouffville and…
We finally made a purchase and had to put our home up for sale. Right when the market started to shift. In such a seller’s market, I never thought I would be nervous to list our home. With homes all around us sitting for weeks we listed our house and … Read More
The team made our home look amazing, which increased our sales potential and views of our listing. The real estate agent sold our home for 100% of asking in less than two weeks. I would highly recommend RE/MAX All-Stars Benczik Kavanagh Real Estate Team to anyone looking to buy or … Read More
Thank you Alon Hillel and his team for helping to declutter and ready our condo for showings without delay. His can do attitude and positive energy was a great help as we worked towards achieving a successful sale. I would recommend Alon to friends & family!
It has been a delight to deal with Leslie Benczik and his entire team. They smoothly guided me through the process of selling my home – from the listing agreement to offers for purchase – everything was clearly explained and with Leslie’s experience his advice was much appreciate. From MLS … Read More
Rachel Kavanagh and her team are a dream come true! I highly recommend working with them to sell your property. We were able to sell our house in 6 days for over asking during an unpredictable and slowing market. You can expect professional, trustworthy, kind, thorough, prompt, and full service. … Read More
Alon Hillel from the Benczik Kavanagh Real Estate Team was a professional and excellent agent from listing to sale of my old house, and then throughout the process of purchasing my new home. He was always quick to respond to inquires and always made time for showings that worked with … Read More
Thanks Rachel and your team for responding very swiftly and professionally to our sudden decision to sell our home. Our home sold in 2 days at a fair price and we are very happy. Our experience was completely positive and we would recommend Rachel and her team to anyone looking … Read More
This was my second time working with Rachel Kavanagh and I couldn’t be happier with the results. The team that she brings to a property know what they are doing. They got my condo staged and on the market quite quickly. The photo’s and video they shot turned out beautifully. … Read More
During the sale of our family home, we wanted to work with a realtor who would be sensitive to our needs. Rachel Kavanagh was excellent – she was professional, attentive, informative and resourceful. Highly recommend!
Rachel Kavanagh is the BEST realtor we have ever worked with. Efficient, honest, hard working and works in your best interest. Great marketing team. Our humble home looked like a gem with her recommendations. Extremely professional. I would definitely use them again.
We highly recommend Carly Whittamore and Debra Ambrose – two outstanding agents on the Benczik team. They are motivated, extremely professional, have a thorough understanding of the marketplace and above all, conduct themselves with the utmost of integrity. Their hard work and creative approach to marketing our building lot in … Read More
Alon and his team has done a professional job in helping us sell our house. We rate them highly with their reliable and professional service!
Alon and the Benczik team we’re absolutely amazing. Alon helped me purchase my first home. He guided me through everything and was always answering my questions. Alon and his team gets the job done no matter what and I will definitely be going back to them in the future. They … Read More
Alon Hillel and the entire REMAX Benczik Team were a pleasure to work with. Alon was patient and informative. We were very impressed with Alon as he went above and beyond our expectations. He was always available to answer our questions or concerns and it was clear he is dedicated, … Read More
I had the honour to work with one of the best area specialist in the Markham area during a very challeging time. . Leslie was incredible to work with, honesty ,knowledge, integrity and professionalism. I can not asked for a better realtor. I would highly recommend him for any of … Read More
I would like to thank you Leslie and his team for their help in selling my property. Their professionalism, client care, support all the way from the listing to the closing day was outstanding and priceless.
It was a pleasure to do business with Benczik and his team, with the entire process from beginning to end being quite favorable. The overall responsiveness and professionalism displayed, gave us complete confidence in their ability to accomplish the task at hand. My family and I found Benczik expertise to … Read More
We are so grateful to Alon Hillel and the Benczik Team who helped us sell our Unionville home with an incredible result! Right from the beginning, we knew that we could trust Alon and his team – the process from start to finish was completely seamless. Everything was explained in … Read More
When my husband and I decided to sell our house, we were faced with an endless selection of realtors. We ultimately chose to work with ReMax All Stars to sell our house. Alon Hillel was extremely helpful and knowledgeable – from staging to listing, to offer night and beyond – … Read More
After 29 years we were nervously excited about selling our family home and moving on to “smaller pastures.” I reached out Rachel and her team as I knew her knowledge of my neighborhood was unsurpassed. The attentiveness, level of professionalism, advice and decisive actions helped us achieve a quick, painless … Read More
What can I say, Rachel and Leslie are the single best agents I have ever had the pleasure of working with. They not only were sensitive to the nature of this sale, but they marketed the property beautifully and strategically and got a price we never dreamed. Professional, skilled and … Read More
Rachel is attentive, knowledgeable and experienced. She was honestly a superstar in helping my family with a very stressful move. Thank you for your insight, patience and warmth. Not to mention helping with big decisions, little details and everything in between. You’re the best! xo
Alon Hillel from the Benczik Team Realty helped my parents sell our family home this summer and buy their new home too. Alon works with a reputable brokerage which is what attracted us to get in touch with them in the first place. It’s true that an established and respected … Read More
Rachel and the Benczik team are the best! We are 3rd time repeat customers and we wish we had more money so that we could keep on using them over and over again… Thank you!
It was a pleasure to have Alon & team as our realtor, we would highly recommend him to anyone selling their home . He was honest & knowledgeable & we sold our home quickly. We were very happy with the outcome
Alon recently helped us buy our second home, and sell our first. He also helped us purchase our first home 5 years ago. He is very knowledgeable and willing to assist in any way he can. He is always available to answer questions. Very professional, happy to recommend Alon! Thank … Read More
Alon was amazing! He helped my husband and I purchase our first home in a crazy real estate market. He was exceptionally patient and professional, always punctual and responsive. 5 star service! I highly recommend working with Alon to anyone!
We worked with Alon Hillel for the sale of our home and hunt for our next home. Alon was attentive, professional and courteous throughout the process. He was quick to understand our interests and needs, guiding us to potential homes that would suit our family. Alon worked with our busy … Read More
We hired Leslie and his team to sell our parents’ house in Stouffville, and we were very happy we did. Every aspect of their service was professional, from staging to photography to marketing and negotiations. They went the extra mile, with a comprehensive market analysis, picture booklets, livestream Zoom walk-throughs, … Read More
Amazing experience, with excellent results! Leslie Benczik and his team did a fantastic job with helping my brother and I sell our parents home. What initially seemed like an overwhelming task was quick, efficient and professional. Leslie’s success in the area, years of experience, local knowledge and attention to detail … Read More
Hands down, Leslie Benzick and RE/MAX All-Stars Benczik Team Reality are the people to go to if you are looking to sell or by property. We have specifically chosen Leslie for a number of properties (bought and sold) and he has always provided us with knowledgeable advise, up to date … Read More
Leslie Benczik is the epitome of professionalism! His manner is gentlemanly, unassuming and always attentive to a myriad of details. We certainly felt in safe and skillful hands. This was proven by Leslie selling our house in just 5 days!! We are truly grateful to Leslie, Susan and this incredibly … Read More
Rachel was fantastic to deal with and looked after everything during what could have been a stressful time selling our home. From coordinating timing, providing a gameplay and strategy as well as having photo’s and making sure every detail was covered. During the process she was constantly in communication with … Read More
We’ve bought and sold again with Alon Hillel, and were again delighted with the experience. His expertise in the Markham Village neighbourhood gave us confidence the first time we worked with him (in 2010) and our trust has only grown since then. He worked hard to find the perfect home … Read More
Leslie Benczik and his team are professionals in every sense of the word. My Mom sought Leslie’s counsel in securing the sale of her property and after meeting with Leslie knew that her needs would be well served. From the very beginning of what was a long and challenging process … Read More